TLoU is #2, since, while a great game, doesn't define the PS3 quite like the Uncharted franchise has. TLoU was one of the greatest ways to end the generation, but Uncharted 2 remains the best game the PS3 ever produced
There's no denying that Kratos and GoW will forever remain PlayStation icons, by GoW 3 the gameplay has become repetitive and stale. But punting hellhound and giving Posiedon eye surgery remain incredibly fun, albeit routine. Personally, I'd throw this at #5