Spark Networks is looking for a hookup. Spark Networks runs many online personals, back in the day, it differentiated itself with offering publishers a private label service.
When I was a sales executive for a men’s online magazine, I had the pleasure of closing a lot of advertising deals with the online personals sites: Match.com, Date.com, Friendfinder.com, AmericanSingles.com, Love.com, etc. All of them. In fact, they were some of our biggest clients. Spark would repeatedly pitch us to have a private label version.
Indeed, some of these sites were doing a killing. To publishers, they represented a welcome revenue stream: at a time when no one was advertising (2001-03), the online personals sites were; either through:
- affiliate marketing programs that paid out a CPA (cost per action, in this case a signup) or
- online advertising deals.
Their business model was lucrative in that people paid them monthly fees AND they gathered a lot of data on end-users.
In fact, oftentimes clients would forget to cancel their memberships even if they found a match, so the recurring fees would repeat many times. Ultimately, the average client would remain for 2 to 3 months, providing lucrative and recurring revenue. Over time, the user data would also prove valuable.
But, I personally think most of these sites lost out on the bigger opportunity, that being said in hindsight of course. The industry makes for a great case study in just how much times change and offer a lessons for today’s high-profile social networking sites.
1 - Once the online advertising market turned around, a lot of these online personals found that obtaining high-quality, low-cost advertising real estate to promote their sites and acquire users proved hard. While previously these marketers were welcome by publishers, by 2004 a lot of demand from global advertisers and agencies created inflation in advertising rates and online personal services - always fickle and very ROI-oriented - could not compete for prime real estate.
2 - Fake profiles. All online personals sites knew that they had some fake profiles. I’m not exactly publishing news by saying that. Very few did anything about it… and ultimately, a lot of users were turned off because of these fake profiles.
3 - Social networking sites such as MySpace, Facebook and what not ended up becoming competitors and eating into the online dating sites’ raison d’etre.
4 - Free dating sites have garnered market share, much the same way that classifieds have taken a hit from Craigslist.org.
5 - Craigslist.org itself launched Missed Connections and Dating categories which further eroded online personals share of the pie.
6 - But the biggest missed opportunity was by these same sites, because many had adopted and fine-tuned a strategy based on subscriptions, none of them really managed to generate sizable advertising revenue despite having a lot of data on users. This was very foolish.
7 - Over time, the emails many of these online personals sites became dated and lost value. After all, say I use an online personal in 2000, I would have used my old email account. I was also single and 22 then. Today I am not really using my old email addresses and I am married and 29… the point is, not all user data is created equally… which takes us to the next point:
8 - Today investors and media are drooling over user data on MySpace and Facebook, but I doubt how valid and accurate most of that data is, and what shelf-life most of that data has anyway. This is a lesson for investors and management at such companies who mortgage their company on user data.
9 - Advertising is the more lucrative business. Spark Networks boasts a market cap of $130M on shrinking revenues of $15M. It’s nothing to sneeze at, but it’s not where it would be if it was an ad-supported model… because a) revenues would not be shrinking and b) the multiples would be higher.
10 - Most importantly, you should sell when you are hot. Online personals would have fetched far higher multiples a few years ago, but today many are seen as passe for the reasons outlined above.
Digg this Blog
Share on Facebook
WatchMojo on Twitter
WatchMojo on YouTube
Add to Favorites
WatchMojo Newsletter
